Affirmative Action: Real Stories

Elyse Duckett
Elyse Duckett
Firefighter, San Francisco Fire Department

Elyse Duckett’s grandmother was a maid for a white family. Her mother was a seamstress. The women in Elyse Duckett’s family held the traditional jobs offered to African American women. At an early age, Duckett saw a different path. She preferred playing in the mud to playing with dolls, wood shop to home economics. She decided to become a firefighter.

A single parent, unemployed, and on welfare, Duckett jumped at the chance to volunteer for the GAIN program which gave AFDC participants the chance to get job skills. GAIN would pay for child care and school supplies while Duckett attended class. So with the support and encouragement of her GAIN counselor and her three women firefighter friends, Duckett enrolled in Fresno City College firefighter school. She was the only woman and the only African American.

In May 1986, as part of the first class under a court-ordered consent decree, Duckett joined the San Francisco Fire Department. The battle to obtain the consent decree began in 1979 when the Black Firefighters Association convinced the director of the San Francisco Black Firefighters to file a class action suit against the department on their behalf.

Previously, black firefighters had been subject to physical harassment by their white colleagues, as well as unfair testing policies. White male firefighters were fed the answers to the lieutenant exam questions by white firefighters already in the department. The decree addressed these problems, and began the process of affirmative action.

Duckett’s journey highlights the positive aspects of affirmative action. A young African American woman was able to fulfill her dream of becoming a firefighter because the GAIN program gave her the skills to advance and the consent decree gave her the equal footing necessary to compete in a white male-dominated trade.

Today, Elyse Duckett is one of the 115 women out of the 1,500 workers in the San Francisco Fire Department.

Belinda Guadarrama
Belinda Guadarrama
Owner and president,
GC Micro

Belinda Guadarrama waged and won a one-woman legal battle against the goliath Defense Logistics Agency (DLA) to ensure proper apportionment of government defense subcontracts to small disadvantaged businesses .

Guadarrama’s company, GC Micro, sells computer software and hardware, principally to the defense and aerospace industries. In 1989, Guadarrama found out that the federally mandated goal of awarding 5 percent of subcontracts to small disadvantaged businesses was repeatedly going unmet. So she began to share this information, detailed on the Department of Defense Standard Form 294, with other mino rity-owned businesses and members of Congress. Soon the Defense Logistics Agency stopped sending her the 294s, claiming that she was circulating sensitive material to competitors. In response, Guadarrama filed a legal suit against the agency for violation of the Freedom of Information Act.

After a four-year court battle—which cost Guadarrama close to $20 million in lost business—the Federal Appellate Court in San Francisco ruled in her favor.

Guadarrama’s efforts forced Lockheed, Boeing and General Dynamics to draw up new contracts for the Air Force’s F-22 advanced tactical fighter jet. They now award 5 percent, instead of the original .007 percent, to small disadvantaged businesses.

“We’re nine years old now, we’ve established ourselves, our pricing is competitive,” says Guadarrama. “But I don’t overlook the fact that had there not been companies willing to work with me early on because of these programs [for disadvantaged businesses], I wouldn’t be here today.”

 

Reprinted with permission from the March/April 1995 issue of MBE MAGAZINE. ©1997 by MINORITY BUSINESS ENTREPENEUR.

 

Jenijoy La Belle
Jenijoy La Belle
Professor of literature,
California Institute of Technology

In 1969, Jenijoy La Belle became the first woman hired as an assistant professor at the California Institute of Technology (Caltech). In 1974, she was unanimously recommended for tenure by the department faculty, and began her five-year battle with the university.

The chairman of the humanities and social sciences division informed her that her tenure was denied due to lack of “scholarly productivity,” even though two men with fewer publications than La Belle had just recently gotten tenure. The literature faculty protested the decision. An outside arbitrator was brought in and La Belle agreed to follow his verdict; she assumed the chairman made the same agreement. But when the arbitrator ruled in favor of La Belle, the chairman denied any such agreement and once again refused La Belle’s tenure.

The chairman then proceeded to change the criteria for tenure to include acceptance of a book for publication by a major university press. In a matter of months, La Belle’s book was accepted by Princeton University Press. She asked for tenure reconsideration. Again, it was denied.

La Belle filed a complaint with the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission. In 1977, it found in her favor, charging Caltech with discrimination against women faculty. The EEOC also discovered that La Belle had been paid less than her male colleagues of equal rank. Armed with these findings, La Belle met with university trustees. They negotiated a settlement: assistant professorship and promi se of an unbiased tenure review in two years. In April 1979, Jenijoy La Belle became the only tenured woman on the Caltech faculty.

“Did I get my position because I’m a woman? Probably not,” she says. “Did I lose it because I’m a woman? Probably. Did I get it back because I’m a woman? You bet.” Jenijoy La Belle continues to teach at Caltech.

Marilu Meyer
Marilu Meyer
Co-founder and president,
Castle Construction Corp.

Women are rare in the construction industry. More rare still are women construction contractors. Marilu Meyer, who started as a school teacher, is a tenacious advocate for women-owned businesses who fits in as well on the job site as in the boardroom.

Meyer’s firm, which specializes in concrete, masonry, carpentry and management, got its big break in 1981 when Chicago’s Department of Transportation (DOT) declared it would make good on its promise to contract with women-owned businesses. Meyer won four contracts, and seven years later her firm became a general contractor.

In 1987, the DOT contracted a $210 million project to renovate Chicago’s expressway (then the country’s largest highway project). When Meyer learned that not one contract had been awarded to a black-owned firm, even though the new expressway cut through predominately black neighborhoods, she was outraged. The slight to black-owned businesses, coupled with accusations that the contracts awarded t o white women-owned businesses were just for show, prompted Meyer to take on the fight for separate goals for women- and minority-owned businesses. She testified before Congress on the issues. And she was appointed by then President Bush to the National Women’s Business Council.

Meyer’s reputation quickly grew as a successful women business owner. The National Association of Women Business Owners named her 1990 Woman of the Year. The Chicago Women’s Business Development Center named her 1990 Entrepreneur of the Year and inducted her into their hall of fame. She is also the past president of the Illinois Chapter of the WCOE.

Marilu Meyer’s personal goal is to see more federal contracts be awarded to women-owned businesses. The tenacity which brought her success in the construction world fuels her as an advocate for women business owners: “I don’t have any problems about stating my beliefs. Somebody’s got to stand up and confront the issues.”

 

Reprinted with permission from the November/December 1992 issue of MBE MAGAZINE. ©1997 by MINORITY BUSINESS ENTREPENEUR.

 



need advice litigation and advocacy join our fight news and media contact ERA about era resources publications search