Update: Federal Judge Clarifies that Harmful Title IX Provision is Unlawful & Should No Longer Be Enforced

August 12. 2021


For Immediate Release
Aug 12, 2021

Media Contact
Jess Eagle, Communications Manager
Equal Rights Advocates
(717) 574-2702
[email protected]


  • Update: On August 24, the U.S. Department of Education released an official statement confirming it will no longer enforce the anti-survivor provision struck down by the court in this ruling, meaning college survivors of sexual violence, and their witnesses, no longer have to submit to live cross-examination at Title IX sexual assault/harassment hearings.
    • Read the Department of Education’s announcement
    • Read the official letter to schools released by the Department of Education Acting Assistant Secretary for Civil Rights, Suzanne B. Goldberg

On August 10, a federal court clarified its ruling in our lawsuit against the U.S. Department of Education and former Secretary Betsy DeVos, confirming that it has deemed unlawful a Trump-era Title IX provision that is harmful to student survivors of sexual violence, and that provision should no longer be enforced under Title IX.

The clarification confirms that the court’s July 28 decision vacated and nullified DeVos’s Title IX “exclusionary rule,” which had required postsecondary schools to exclude all evidence and statements made by any party or witness who did not submit to cross-examination at a live hearing.

Under the now nullified provision, survivors had been required to be cross-examined at a live hearing by their harmer or an advisor of the harmer’s choice in order for the survivor’s previous written and oral statements to be considered as evidence in their case. It also meant that the harmer’s previous statements — including confessions or apologies — could be excluded from evidence if the harmer simply refused to be cross-examined.

Confirmed by the court’s clarification, its ruling means colleges and universities can now consider crucial evidence — such as police reports, rape kits, and statements from witnesses — that they were previously required to ignore if the relevant witnesses were unable or unwilling to be present and cross-examined at the Title IX hearing. This harmful Trump-era provision took effect nearly one year ago, on August 14, 2020.

In addition to finding the provision unlawful, the court called it “arbitrary and capricious,” saying it rendered Title IX hearings into “a remarkably hollow gesture.” Thus, the court said, it is clear that “the Department failed, even implicitly, to consider the consequences” of the provision.

Read more about the court’s July 28 decision here.

The lawsuit was brought by Equal Rights AdvocatesVictim Rights Law CenterChicago Alliance Against Sexual ExploitationLegal Voice, and several survivors, including ERA clients. We were represented by Morrison & Foerster, National Women’s Law Center, and Diane Rosenfeld.

Stay Connected & Take Action

Legal Advice & Resources / Consejos y Recursos legales

Know Your Rights

Learn what your rights are so you can navigate your situation and make the best decision for you.

Your Rights at Work
Your Rights at School

Contact Us

We may be able to provide free legal help for the following issues at school: gender and LGBTQI+ discrimination, sexual harassment, sexual assault, and pregnancy or parenting discrimination.

Apply for Legal Help

Learn More

We have trained legal advocates and lawyers on staff to guide you through your legal issue.

We're helping women, families, workers & students navigate COVID-19

Conozca Sus Derechos

Aprende sus derechos para que puedas navegar su situación y tomar la mejor decisión para ti.

Sus Derechos en el Trabajo

Contáctenos

Posible que podamos proveer ayuda legal por gratis por los siguientes problemas en el trabajo o la escuela: discriminación basado en el género o por LGBTQI+, acoso sexual, asalto sexual, y discriminación basado en el embarazo o por ser padre/madre.

Contáctenos

Nuestro servicio de asesoramiento por teléfono está cerrado por ahora

En este momento, no estamos recibiendo solicitudes dejadas por un recado de teléfono. Sin embargo, usted puede someter una solicitud para una consulta por la manera de hacer clic en el links "Empleo" o "Educación."